Comparison · UK debt solutions

IVA vs DMP vs DRO vs bankruptcy (UK comparison)

This page gives a high-level comparison of four common UK debt solutions. It is general information only and does not tell you which option, if any, is right for you.

IVA

Formal agreement overseen by an insolvency practitioner.

DMP

Informal plan to pay back debts over a longer period.

DRO

Formal option for people with low income, low assets and lower debt.

Bankruptcy

Legal process that can write off debts but has major consequences.

At a glance

Feature IVA DMP DRO Bankruptcy
Type of solution Formal, legally binding Informal arrangement Formal, legally binding Formal, legal process
Typical duration Often around 5–6 years Varies depending on payments Usually 12 months Usually 12 months
Protection from creditors Yes, if IVA stays in place Limited; creditors can change terms Yes, if DRO is approved Yes, subject to rules
Impact on credit file Significant, often 6 years Can be negative while in place Significant, often 6 years Significant, often 6 years

When people might explore each option

The points below are general only. They are not recommendations. Individual advice should always come from an FCA-regulated adviser or free debt charity that can look at your full situation.

IVAs

IVAs are sometimes explored by people who have a regular income, owe a significant amount of unsecured debt, and can afford a steady payment each month but not enough to clear everything in a reasonable time at the current rates. They are usually considered where people meet the eligibility criteria set by the provider and are willing to commit to a long-term, formal arrangement.

DMPs

Debt Management Plans are often used as an informal way of paying back unsecured debts over a longer period. Some people look at DMPs when they can afford something towards their debts but cannot manage the contractual minimum payments. Because DMPs are informal, creditors may agree to reduce or stop interest and charges, but they do not have to.

DROs

Debt Relief Orders are a formal option with strict eligibility rules. They are generally designed for people with relatively low levels of qualifying debt, limited spare income and few assets. For those who qualify and complete a DRO, many included debts may be written off after a set period, but there can be important consequences, particularly for future borrowing and certain roles.

Bankruptcy

Bankruptcy is a legal process that can sometimes write off debts more quickly, but it can also have serious long-term effects. It may be explored where other options are not suitable or have been ruled out, or where someone’s circumstances mean that maintaining payments into a long arrangement would be unrealistic. How bankruptcy affects assets, income and future opportunities depends on individual circumstances and the rules in place at the time.

This overview does not cover every detail or option. It is intended only as a starting point for understanding broad differences.

You might be interested in…

Ad · Affiliate link

These are commercial partner links via Awin.

Credit & borrowing

Compare credit offers such as loans or credit cards.

See credit offers

Personal loans & balance transfer cards

Combine debts with a loan or move a balance to a promotional card.

See offers

Budgeting tools & calculators

Explore our tools and calculators to help manage your money.

See options

Borrowing always costs money. Please make sure you can afford the repayments before taking on new credit.

If you click through and apply for a product, we will receive a commission.

Need more general information about formal debt solutions?

If you’re struggling with debt, you can find impartial guidance at MoneyHelper or talk to a free debt charity such as StepChange, National Debtline or Money Advice Trust.

Some links on this site are affiliate links. If you click through and choose to act on the information provided, we will receive a commission at no extra cost to you. General information only; not financial advice.

This comparison is general information only. It does not include every detail or option and does not tell you which solution, if any, is suitable for you. Always seek individual advice from an FCA‑regulated adviser or free debt charity.